Hidden-Gem Lakes You Haven’t Heard Of (But Should)

Northern Indiana — especially around Steuben County and the Fremont/Angola region — is packed with over 100 natural lakes, but only a handful get all the attention. Beyond favorites like Lake James, Crooked Lake, and Clear Lake, there are quiet, scenic, and surprisingly affordable lakes that offer amazing beauty, peaceful living, and great fishing.

Here are the top hidden-gem lakes that deserve a spot on your radar.

1. Big Turkey Lake – A Spacious, Quiet Escape

Location: Just east of Hudson, near the Steuben/LaGrange lineWhy it’s a hidden gem:Big Turkey is much larger than people realize — and one of the most underrated fishing lakes in the region.

What makes Big Turkey special:

• Excellent bass, bluegill, and walleye fishing

• Wide, shallow areas that warm quickly in spring

• Affordable lakefront homes compared to major lakes

• Calm atmosphere perfect for paddling and pontooning

It’s ideal for buyers who want big water without big crowds.

2. Tamarack Lake – Peaceful, Rustic, and Untouched

Location: Northwest Steuben CountyWhy it’s a hidden gem:Tamarack Lake is quiet, lightly developed, and surrounded by natural landscapes.

What makes Tamarack special:

• Incredible wildlife viewing

• Great for kayakers and naturalists

• Minimal boat traffic

• Perfect for those craving privacy and serenity

This lake is about nature first, making it one of the most peaceful escapes in the county.

3. Ball Lake – Cozy, Charming, and Family-Friendly

Location: Near Hamilton & the Ohio state lineWhy it’s a hidden gem:Ball Lake has a small-town, welcoming vibe — perfect for relaxing weekends.

Highlights:

• Good mix of seasonal cottages and year-round homes

• Excellent fishing, especially for panfish

• Narrow shape that reduces boat traffic

• Budget-friendly lake real estate

If you want an approachable, friendly lake community, Ball Lake delivers.

4. Long Lake – Scenic Water with the Perfect Pace

Location: Southwest of AngolaWhy it’s a hidden gem:Long Lake is calm, scenic, and just the right size for relaxed lake days.

Why locals love it:

• Beautiful tree-lined shores

• Quiet boating, kayaking, and sunset cruising

• Less expensive than nearby Hamilton or Lake James

• Low boat traffic = ideal for families

Long Lake blends affordability with natural beauty.

5. Golden Lake – Clear Water & Peaceful Living

Location: Northwest Steuben CountyWhy it’s a hidden gem:Golden Lake has surprisingly clear water for its size — and a reputation for tranquility.

What makes it unique:

• Clean, clear water

• Excellent for swimming and paddleboarding

• Very little development = minimal noise

• Strong fishing opportunities

This is the lake people move to when they want peace, privacy, and clean water without paying Clear Lake prices.

Why These Lakes Are “Hidden Gems”

Most buyers look only at the big names: Lake James, Crooked Lake, Clear Lake, Hamilton Lake. But hidden-gem lakes offer:

• More privacy

• Lower property prices

• Less boat traffic and noise

• Amazing fishing

• Stronger value for first-time lake buyers

• Calm, nature-driven lifestyles

If you're looking for lake living without the crowds — these lakes deserve a serious look.

Final Thoughts

Northern Indiana’s hidden-gem lakes offer some of the most peaceful and affordable waterfront living opportunities in the Midwest. Whether you want quiet weekends, incredible fishing, or a family cabin without the premium price tag, these lakes provide the perfect alternative to the big, busy lakes everyone else talks about.