🎣 Fishing Hotspots in Steuben County: Where Locals Go to Catch Big

Gabe Cerny
Oct 17
3 min read

Known as Indiana’s Lake Country, Steuben County is home to 101 natural lakes — making it one of the state’s most beloved fishing destinations. From trophy bass to northern pike and bluegill, the waters surrounding Fremont and Angola are teeming with opportunities for anglers of all experience levels. Whether you fish for sport, food, or peace of mind, these local hotspots promise unforgettable days on the water.

1. Lake James – The King of Steuben County Fishing

Located within Pokagon State Park, Lake James is the region’s largest and most popular lake.

What you’ll catch: Largemouth bass, smallmouth bass, walleye, northern pike, bluegill, and crappie.
Why locals love it: Excellent fishing conditions year-round, public boat launches, and easy access to marinas.
Pro tip: Early mornings and late evenings near weed beds are prime times for landing big bass.

2. Crooked Lake – Great for Families and Casual Anglers

Crooked Lake offers a more relaxed fishing experience but with plenty of action.

What you’ll catch: Largemouth bass, perch, crappie, and sunfish.
Why locals love it: Calm water, multiple access points, and family-friendly shorelines.
Pro tip: Try fishing near docks or drop-offs for steady bites — this lake is known for generous panfish populations.

3. Hamilton Lake – Big Action for Serious Anglers

One of the largest lakes near the town of Hamilton, this destination attracts anglers from across Indiana and Ohio.

What you’ll catch: Muskie, bass, bluegill, and northern pike.
Why locals love it: Depth and diversity — Hamilton Lake’s multiple basins provide fishing variety all year.
Pro tip: Troll deeper channels in summer; the muskie population here surprises even veteran fishers.

4. Clear Lake – Crystal Waters and Clear Catches

True to its name, Clear Lake’s spring-fed waters make it one of Indiana’s most scenic fishing spots.

What you’ll catch: Bass, walleye, and perch.
Why locals love it: The clarity makes it great for sight fishing and kayak fishing.
Pro tip: Use lighter line and natural bait colors — the fish here can see everything!

5. Jimmerson and Snow Lakes – Peaceful Yet Productive

Both lakes are part of the Lake James chain and are local favorites for quiet, steady fishing.

What you’ll catch: Crappie, perch, and walleye.
Why locals love it: Less boat traffic, calm waters, and reliable bites.
Pro tip: During spring and fall, drift-fishing along the drop-offs yields impressive catches.

6. Pleasant Lake and Ball Lake – Hidden Gems Worth Exploring

Smaller in size but rich in fishing charm, these lakes offer serenity and a slower pace.

What you’ll catch: Bluegill, crappie, and smallmouth bass.
Why locals love it: Peaceful mornings, easy shore access, and minimal competition.
Pro tip: Early summer is peak time for panfish — bring ultralight gear for fun action.

7. Ice Fishing Hotspots in Winter

Steuben County’s fishing season doesn’t end when the lakes freeze — it just transforms.

Best lakes for ice fishing: Lake James, Hamilton Lake, and Snow Lake.
Popular catches: Bluegill, perch, and crappie.
Pro tip: Locals recommend early morning setups with small jigs tipped with wax worms for the best success.

Final Thoughts

Whether you’re after trophy bass on Lake James or a quiet day casting for bluegill on Pleasant Lake, Steuben County offers fishing experiences as diverse as its 101 lakes. Combine that with friendly communities, beautiful scenery, and thriving lakefront properties, and it’s easy to see why so many call this corner of northeast Indiana home — or wish they did.

So grab your rod, pack your tackle box, and get ready to explore Steuben County’s best-kept fishing secrets. The big catch might be waiting just a cast away.